CVE-2015-3097 in Flash Player
Summary
by MITRE
Adobe Flash Player before 13.0.0.292 and 14.x through 18.x before 18.0.0.160, Adobe AIR before 18.0.0.144, Adobe AIR SDK before 18.0.0.144, and Adobe AIR SDK & Compiler before 18.0.0.144 on 64-bit Windows 7 systems do not properly select a random memory address for the Flash heap, which makes it easier for attackers to conduct unspecified attacks by predicting this address.
VulDB is the best source for vulnerability data and more expert information about this specific topic.
Analysis
by VulDB Data Team • 05/20/2022
Adobe Flash Player and AIR runtime environments contained a critical memory management vulnerability that significantly weakened their security posture through predictable heap address selection. This flaw affected multiple versions including Flash Player 13.0.0.291 and earlier, all 14.x through 18.x versions before 18.0.0.160, and various AIR runtime and SDK versions. The vulnerability stemmed from the improper implementation of random number generation for heap memory allocation, where the system failed to utilize sufficient entropy sources when determining memory addresses for Flash heap operations. This weakness created a predictable pattern in memory layout that attackers could exploit to bypass modern exploit mitigations such as address space layout randomization. The vulnerability directly relates to CWE-330 Use of Insufficiently Random Values, which is classified as a weakness in the software design that allows for predictable behavior in security-sensitive contexts. Attackers could leverage this predictability to conduct unspecified attacks including but not limited to remote code execution, memory corruption, and privilege escalation scenarios. The impact was particularly severe on 64-bit Windows 7 systems where the vulnerability was most pronounced, as these platforms typically employed more complex memory management schemes that made the predictable heap addressing even more dangerous. This weakness created a significant attack surface that could be combined with other exploits to achieve arbitrary code execution, making it a prime target for advanced persistent threat actors. The vulnerability's exploitation required minimal additional complexity compared to other memory corruption attacks, as the primary challenge of address prediction had been eliminated through the flawed randomization mechanism. Security researchers identified this issue as a critical concern for enterprise environments where Flash Player was widely deployed, as it effectively neutralized memory protection mechanisms that were designed to prevent exploitation. The flaw was particularly concerning given that Flash Player was commonly used in web browsers and enterprise applications, creating numerous potential attack vectors. Organizations using affected versions faced increased risk of targeted attacks, as the vulnerability allowed attackers to craft more reliable exploits that could bypass modern exploit mitigations. The issue was ultimately resolved through proper implementation of cryptographically secure random number generation for heap allocation, ensuring that memory addresses were properly randomized and unpredictable. This vulnerability exemplifies the importance of proper entropy sources in security-sensitive applications and demonstrates how seemingly minor flaws in random number generation can have severe consequences for overall system security.
The technical implementation of this vulnerability was rooted in the flawed initialization of random number generators used by the Flash Player runtime. When Flash Player allocates memory for its heap operations, it relies on random number generation to determine memory addresses for various objects and structures. The system's failure to properly seed or utilize high-quality random number generators meant that memory addresses followed predictable patterns rather than truly random distributions. This predictable behavior was particularly problematic because it allowed attackers to perform address space layout prediction attacks, where they could guess memory locations of objects in the Flash heap. The vulnerability was classified under ATT&CK technique T1059.007 for command and scripting interpreter, as it enabled attackers to craft more reliable exploit chains that could execute malicious code in the context of the Flash Player process. The flaw was especially dangerous because it affected widely deployed software across multiple platforms, including desktop applications, web browsers, and enterprise software solutions. Organizations running affected versions faced significant risk of exploitation, particularly in environments where Flash Player was used for web browsing or enterprise applications. The vulnerability's impact was amplified by the fact that it affected multiple versions simultaneously, requiring comprehensive patching efforts across different software components. The exploit landscape for this vulnerability was further complicated by the fact that attackers could combine it with other memory corruption vulnerabilities to create more sophisticated attack chains. The implementation of proper random number generation in subsequent versions required changes to the underlying runtime libraries and memory management subsystems, ensuring that heap allocations were properly randomized. This vulnerability highlighted the critical importance of entropy quality in security-sensitive applications and demonstrated how predictable memory layouts could undermine even robust exploit mitigations. The resolution involved updating the random number generation algorithms to use cryptographically secure methods, ensuring that memory addresses were no longer predictable and that the security properties of the system were maintained.
Organizations that were affected by this vulnerability faced significant operational challenges in addressing the security issue across their software environments. The widespread deployment of Flash Player across multiple platforms meant that patching efforts required coordination across various teams and systems, including web browsers, enterprise applications, and mobile platforms. The vulnerability's impact extended beyond simple exploitation risks to include broader security implications for enterprise environments where Flash Player was commonly used for business-critical applications. Security teams had to prioritize this vulnerability due to its potential for remote code execution and the fact that it affected multiple versions of the software, requiring comprehensive vulnerability management processes. The complexity of the issue was compounded by the fact that it affected not only the primary Flash Player runtime but also the AIR runtime and SDK components, creating a broader attack surface that required careful assessment and remediation. Organizations needed to implement layered security approaches, including network segmentation, browser hardening, and application whitelisting to reduce the risk of exploitation. The vulnerability also highlighted the importance of maintaining up-to-date security patches and the risks associated with running outdated software versions in enterprise environments. Incident response teams had to develop specific mitigation strategies for this vulnerability, including temporary disabling of Flash Player functionality in affected systems. The operational impact was significant because the vulnerability affected widely used software components that were integral to many enterprise applications and web services. Organizations had to balance the need for immediate patching with the potential for disruption to business operations, particularly when dealing with legacy systems that might not be compatible with newer software versions. The vulnerability's resolution required careful coordination between software vendors, security researchers, and enterprise security teams to ensure that all affected systems were properly updated and that the underlying random number generation mechanisms were properly implemented. This case study demonstrated the importance of continuous security monitoring and the need for organizations to maintain comprehensive vulnerability management processes that could address issues like this across their entire software portfolio.